Salty Ask List

gsut:

  1. What OTPs in your fandom(s) do you just not get?*
  2. Are there any popular fandom OTPs you only BroTP?*
  3. Have you ever unfollowed someone over a fandom opinion?
  4. Do you have a NoTP in your fandom? Are they a popular OTP?*
  5. Has fandom ever ruined a pairing for you?*
  6. Has fandom ever made you enjoy a pairing you previously hated?*
  7. Is there anything you used to like but can’t stand now?*
  8. Have you received anon hate? What about?*
  9. Most disliked character(s)? Why?
  10. Most disliked arc? Why?
  11. Is there an unpopular character you like that the fandom doesn’t? Why?
  12. Is there an unpopular arc that you like that the fandom doesn’t? Why?
  13. Unpopular opinion about XXX character?
  14. Unpopular opinion about your fandom?
  15. Unpopular opinion about the manga/show?
  16. If you could change anything in the show, what would you change?
  17. Instead of XYZ happening, I would have made ABC happen…
  18. Does not shipping something ‘popular’ mean you’re in denial and/or biased?
  19. What is the one thing you hate most about your fandom?
  20. What is the purest ship in the fandom?
  21. What are your thoughts on crack ships?
  22. Popular character you hate?
  23. Unpopular character you love?
  24. Would you recommend XXX to a friend? Why or why not?
  25. How would you end XXX/Would you change the ending of XXX?
  26. Most shippable character?
  27. Least shippable character?

*several of these questions are taken from a list that was not rebloggable

Craver from the sounds of it could have been the “Molder” lady from Batman and Robin Eternal who “molded” mother’s “children” into perfect soldiers since she did have mental abilities to show memories like that.

Oh! Yes, I think you’re right! (Which, okay no excuse now not to have Cass as the Bat’s newest enforcer/weapon under heavy Ride-along control -combining David Cain with AU Fascist!Bruce- who will be sent Terminator style to hunt down Babs but eventually through freedom and learning becomes heroic Cass)

In my defense, I have only read B&RE once, even if it is one of the few nu52 arcs I have read.

ayellowbirds:

dr-archeville:

blackphoenix1977:

chaoswolf1982:

ayellowbirds:

thefingerfuckingfemalefury:

why-i-love-comics:

Kate Kane had specific hanukkah gelt made with the Batwoman symbol and Star of David

Batman Annual #1 – “Stag” (2017)
written by Steve Orlando
art by Riley Rossmo & Ivan Plascencia

I LOVE KATE SO MUCH OKAY OH MY GOSH 😀

SHE IS A GIFT ❤

the only thing that would make this better would be if they actually acknowledged that Bruce is Jewish.

He is? News to me.

I believe that he’s Jewish on his mother’s side? I’m not sure.

Yes.  A flashback in Batwoman vol.02:no.25 (January 2014) confirmed the familial relationship between Kate Kane and Bruce Wayne (son of Martha Wayne, born Martha Kane) as being cousins.  (Kate’s father Jacob & Bruce’s mother Martha were siblings.)  Since the Kanes which Kate belongs to have been established as Jewish, and since Jewishness is matrilineal, this means Bruce Wayne is Jewish.

According to this 2005-07 article, most depictions of Batman/Bruce imply he was probably raised Catholic or Episcopalian.  Even if this is the case, though, my understanding is that he’d still be considered Jewish.

It’s also established that things are… awkward, between the Kanes and the Waynes. At least back during the wonky timeline established in 2010′s The Return of Bruce Wayne (specifically, issue #5), the Kanes were convinced of the absolute worst about Thomas Wayne. The last decade or so has seen a lot of stories where accusations of terrible crimes and corruption are made against the late Waynes—as well as poor Alfred, having been their employee and close companion—and it’s often ambiguous whether or not there’s any truth to them. Especially since we’re talking about multiple writers with radically different plans for Bruce. In any case, the issue i mentioned above saw a time-lost amnesiac Bruce investigating his own parents’ murder. While he’s unknowingly speaking to his grandparents, we see this:

image
image

The cloud of insects harassing zayde Roddy and bubbe Betsy are emphatically identified as wasps, but this is Grant Morrison writing, and the cocky schmuck isn’t the type to resist a “WASPs” pun. 

Fast-forwarding to the issue Doc mentions, we see that Bruce is still somewhat connected to his mother’s side of the family… but it’s only via a funeral that he seems to meet up with them.

image

If anything, the living Kanes seem to know Alfred better than Bruce, and their interactions with him seem fond and familiar.

image

Whereas we get this painfully formal and stilted “Cousin Bette” from Bruce. It seems like depressing formal functions like funerals are the only places Bruce sees any of his family.

image

The Kanes are distant from Bruce, and even in their more tender interactions with him, he’s linked to tragedy. A reminder of people who were lost. You’d think having had living relatives to visit with would have meant less time alone for Bruce after his parents died, but it’s made clear in that time-travel story that, even in tragedy, they aren’t comfortable having him around.

image

All in all, it seems a lot like Bruce is kept out of his Jewish heritage because that side of the family saw his father as something of a shegetz. Being Martha’s son means he’s in the tribe, but Thomas being his dad—and it’s often emphasized that Bruce looks so much like Thomas—means that he’s ostracized. There’s all kinds of suppositions i could make about the hows and whys, the exotified coding of Bruce as foreign in spite of his whiteness, even amidst the goyish-passing Kanes, the insularity and paranoia of Gothamites. And Bruce’s convictions about what he needs to be, what Gotham needs… well, that doesn’t help bring him in, does it? 

All that said, i could write a whole huge tangent on the presentation of the Kanes as assimilated. Don’t let me ever write a real Batman story, because it’ll just be about Ashkenazic-American and Anglo-Sephardic heritage and the tensions between different Jewish ethnicities and early Tri-State Area culture clashes. Probably some stupid nods to the connection between “Gotham” as a mythical city of fools, and the Wise Men of Chelm.

10, 11, 12?

10. Most disliked arc? Why?

For the Silmarillion? Despite my avowed disinterest in the fandom hyper-focus on Noldor in Tirion during the time of the Two Trees, which because I no longer activity seek Silmarillion content outside of myself and my small corner, it probably not as popular anymore for all I know … in the Silmarillion it’s the Second Age stuff. Númenor? Drown the place. Eregion and all that Celebrimbor and Annatar story? Snore.

Okay, If I go into DC Comics where there are definite arcs and an absolute MINEFIELD of bad writing and butchered characterizations to choose, well, that excess of riches means that I’ve been trying to avoid reading the known worst-of-the-worst.

I didn’t like most of Morrison’s Batman Incorporated, with the exception of Stephanie’s chapter. Just, ew no. I guess I’m not a Morrison fan. The Court of Owls still sounds stupid; most Illuminati conspiracy theory secret society plots do. Battle for the Cowl is infamously bad.

But hey, Star Wars! There’s one where I read a lot of bad stories until it got to DelRey and Vong and beyond bad. For Clone Wars, when they brought back Maul, I was done. But the Mortis Arc I disliked and don’t understand why it was so loved. But with the Bantam Era EU I waiver between the Jedi Academy trilogy awfulness and Zahn’s technically better written trilogy but I actually hate it more for creating all of Zahn’s pet characters and canonizing that Dark Horse comic arc and Mara Jade’s ‘Grey Jedi’ bullshit, Thrawn the Villain Gary Stu, Karde bad puns more original pet characters propped up by the author, Luuke, etc… There was a book where the main villain was the return of the one-armed wampa-eater yeti thing, but at least it wasn’t treated in fandom as awesome as Zahn’s works.

11. Is there an unpopular character you like that the fandom doesn’t? Why?

I love and defend Elwing and Indis and have since my first read-through, and it pains me that they are unpopular and outright villainized (in ways that often hint at underlying misogyny) in areas of the fandom. I strongly sympathized with them from the get-go. Also Eöl the asshole genius who is on the wrong side of the fandom’s imperialistic sympathies.

Jason Todd has a large and sympathetic fandom nowadays, hooray. Jessica Cruz is definitely popular in the DC fandom, though I wish Simon Baz got more love because I like the two of them together. Plus Simon with his very relateable ‘i don’t really want to live on this terrible earth’ and his white mage girl style powers of healing and seer-prophecy while having that aggressive fighter dude personality is entertaining – let him become the support character deep inside him as he cheers on Jessica and helps her overcome her anxieties to become the tank that protects him. 

12. Is there an unpopular arc that you like that the fandom doesn’t? Why?

Silm fandom- so those two lines about the Bór are the most intriguing part of the Fifth Battle, am I right? Yes?

…Vanyar and Sindar anything.

The fact that the freaking ‘Lay of Leithian’ feels like it isn’t popular in the Simarillion online fandom is just bizarre.

Okay, here’s a great answer: Attack of the Clones is the most enjoyable Star Wars film for me to watch. Romance, Obi Wan being a detective, political machinations but not too much, wide range of locales.

even though I know at least some of the answer to #22 I’m asking anyway because reading your rants NEVER GETS OLD. Also #18 only because I have no idea what the reasoning behind that question even IS so I’m curious about your take on it.

22. Popular character you hate?

Oh gods. Rand al’Thor is a fucking bigamist, and his chapters from around book four start to become nearly unreadable. Why should I care about his deteriorating mental state when he is written as this asshole who’s overwhelming sexist-coded guilt complex isn’t interesting? Oh the weight of prophecies and being the messiah of the world~ Bleuch. You’re why I don’t like Chosen One main protag figures. I hate his shacking up with Min -who is the ‘not like other girls, I’m enlightened unfeminine and cool’ that I really don’t like.

…Oh, you wanted that other popular character heget hate rant? Kylo Ren is boring Okay, okay. Look, Fëanor is not a champion of free will. Fëanor is a champion of HIS ability to control his autonomy and fate, and he wants subservience from others. Why else to make his sons and then have them reaffirm that Oath? His disgusting xenophobia should be called out more; the rally in Tirion during the Darkening am I blind here to be the only one that sees the parallels to a fascist rally and coup d’etat? Like, hell, that scene is so grossing unsettling. It makes my skin crawl.

18. Does not shipping something ‘popular’ mean you’re in denial and/or biased?

I think it’s asking if something feels a sense of smug superiority for not following the popular trend. Hipster mindset.

Look, shipping is based off a person’s subjective feelings, and pretending it’s not and is motivated by rational thought or purity or progressive values is an ugly fandom problem. Do i not ship popular ships? Yes. Because I am biased; everyone is.

3, 4!!!

3. Have you ever unfollowed someone over a fandom opinion?

I’ve not followed people because of the amount of Maedhros or Fëanorians in general they had on their blog, and yes, did unfollow Silm fandom people because of it (not many). Won’t call out who.

In a similar vein, I started listening to a podcast but immediately stopped and deleted that podcast because the main host proudly admitted to being one of those people that called in to vote for Jason Todd’s death back in the 80s. That is an insta-unfollow for me, like unironically thinking Fëanor was right to steal the Swanships (or anything else)

4. Do you have a NoTP in your fandom? Are they a popular OTP?*

Oh, let me make a hand-motion over my mouth. Okay. Fingon/Maedhros -the most popular OTP in the Silm fandom- only escapes from being a NoTP from me because I low-key despise both of them (yes, both). Most of the other non-canon m/m slash ships I tend to not care about but also don’t care enough about the characters to care, i.e. Angbang, Silverfisting. Haleth/Caranthir is popular and is a NoTP.

Batfam I don’t ship Dickbabs, and it’s nearly inescapable in general Batfam focused fics. It’s a rare but precious to me fic that goes with Dickkory instead. Aside from that, I hate SuperWonder, but also SuperBats and WonderBat. All three are popular, but only Superman/WonderWoman is not as popular and gets routinely and rightfully hated by the larger fandom.