tolkienmemegirl:

Andreth & Aegnor by Ekukanova

#really when i think of aegnor’s issues with andreth’s fate i always wonder about the impact of the kinslaying on him idk#might be not at all what jirt intended but like… you know#it’s all i can think about when i think of them hahaha sob (via @crocordile)

Juliana, …um, so to say this politely? NO. Did not need that, my heart did not need that connection emphasized.

100% agreed on the beard plothole. Beardhole. And I can totally get behind Cirdan + Gil-galad’s mother no matter who the dad was, especially since she was Falathren in at least one version!

Just have it either ‘elves can grow beards if they really really want to’ or ‘círdan is secretly half-dwarf and this is awkward so never talked about’

My Fingon sucks at making friends and doing the extroverted make good friends and do the minimum for politics (Turgon, however? great at making friends and keeping a large friend group from getting splintered by drama) Therefore Fingon needs his wife.

Trying to avoid the obvious candidates, so: Círdan!

  • favorite thing about them

Here’s one of the most important elves in the entire universe. He’s not a king or son of a king, and though he does fight, why is he important? He builds ships. He ensures that others have ships in which to travel places. Ships are really important, just as important if not more important in a positive cultural way than all that cursed gems and jewelry littering Middle-earth. Fuck yeah, Shipwright!

  • least favorite thing about them

uh the ring stuff maybe? that he gets a beard but then Tolkien says old elves get beards but then never mentions beards on the elves that would likely be as old as Círdan so this still feels plothole-ish to this day

  • favorite line

“I will dwell by the grey shores until the last ship sails.

  • brOTP

Him and Elu, the absolute sense of history and how Círdan is the one to send the heads up that hey, these new empire builders are lying to our faces but I don’t have confirmation and all so check their references. Him and Finrod. Not the biggest Gandalf ‘stan but they cool

  • OTP

Círdan is very ace to me. If I have to think of him in a romantic-coded relationship, it’s a poly relationship with Ossë and Uinen

  • nOTP

Gil-galad. That’s his son.

  • random headcanon

aside from the sigil, even keeping Gil-galad as Fingon’s son, I don’t imagine any close friendship between him and Fingon, but Círdan was close to Gil-galad’s Sindarin mother and especially Finrod is playing intermediary. He sleeps in a hammock and modern vibes would be either a grizzled warm Maine lighthouse keeper or a chill Jimmy Buffett listening Florida Keys retiree

  • unpopular opinion

I don’t like him with long beards, keep it under a foot. Also that head-canon interpretation that he was in any way negative towards the Valar is projecting

  • song i associate with them

Not a single song itself, because then I’m talking Elu or Elmo, but bands like Lord Huron, Fleet Foxes, Ben Howard. Any modern nuFolk

  • favorite picture of them

This one is particularly fun

@crocordile tagged for the last line meme (and between them and bekka, most everyone has been tagged. Here’s the latest two:

As a child, Gadwar found his brother’s adherence to rules and justice vexing, for he could do no mischief within his brother’s presence. No sneaking of sweets, no innocent lies, no shirking of lessons to go play with Galuven as watchful nursemaid.

Re-writing Galad Damodred to fit the Silm is fun (and not just because of the whole World’s Most Beautiful Man):

When he thought no one could hear him, Gadwar’s father would complain how he missed his chance to cross aboard the stolen Swan-ships, and had that not happened, he and his family would not have had to cross the ice desert. Had he boarded the ships, his first wife would not have had the opportunity to decide to disappear into the darkness to die of despair somewhere in the fathomless cold. Gadwar’s older brother had been even younger than Princess Idril during the crossing and had little memory of his mother. When Heledir, Bân, and other veterans of the Helecaraxë spoke of the endless darkness and cold and of everyone who died during the crossing, Galuven could only offer vague memories of a freezing nose. Thus, Galuven lacked the resentment that plagued their father. Tarlangon had been an opportunist searching for power, latching first to Fëanor’s reactionary party, then switching to Fingolfin because of the far greater number of followers. Any words that would grant him more status at court and more public attention to his studies and publications Gadwar’s father said, with whatever pronunciation he needed to. Tarlangon did not possess the single-minded devotion and loyalty demanded of those allowed to board the stolen Swan-ships.

Anyways, there was no opportunity for him to rejoin the following of Fëanor’s sons once he remarried.

Gadwar’s father married his mother, a noble woman of the Mithrim Sindar, for political stability and power – and to have someone to care for his young son. How much his father loved his mother, Gadwar could not guess, and his mother spoke of Tarlangon in only a fond but distant neutrality. Meluiniel’s own motives for marriage had been equally calculated, she once admitted in private, as a young Gadwar once again listened from corners that he was not meant to. She had no strong desire to be a wife, but she strongly wished to be a mother.

Galuven treated Meluiniel as if she were his birth-mother. He had little memory of his first mother and little reason to cling to her memory. Meluiniel taught him to read and write, to ride a horse, to account his finances, to sing and dance, and to comport himself as a righteous man. The last was a particular sticking point to Gadwar, for if he were to describe his older half-brother with a single phrase, it was that Galuven was concerned that his every action be morally just. Perhaps it was fortuitous that Tanlangen died a year after Gadwar and his twin sister were born, for Galuven disapproved strongly of his status as Exile.

“Tell me where you are put up, and I will bring word, or send it, as soon as I locate a suitable vessel.”

If Elayne was right, he could no more lie than could an Aes Sedai who had sworn the Three Oaths, but still she hesitated. A mistake here could be her last. She had a right to take risks for herself, but this risk involved Elayne too. And Thom and Juilin, for that matter; they were her responsibility, whatever they wanted to think. But she was here, and the decision had to be hers. Not that it might be any other way, frankly.

“Light, woman, what more do you want of me?” Galad growled, halfraising his hands as though to grab her shoulders. Uno’s blade was between them in a flash of bright steel, but Elayne’s brother actually brushed it aside like a twig, and paid it no more mind than one. “I mean no harm to you, now or ever; I swear it by my mother’s name. You say that you are what you are? I know what you are. And what you are not. Perhaps half the reason I wear this,” he touched an edge of his snowy cloak, “is because the Tower sent you out — you and Elayne and Egwene — for the Light knows what reason, when you are what you are. It was like sending a boy who has just learned to hold a sword into battle, and I will never forgive them. There is still time for both of you to turn aside; you do not have to carry that sword. The Tower is too dangerous for you or my sister, especially now. Half the world is become too dangerous for you! Let me help you to safety.” The tightness slid from his voice, though it took on a raw edge. “I beg you, Nynaeve. If anything happened to Elayne… I halfwish that Egwene were with you, so I could…” Scrubbing a hand through his hair, he looked left and right, searching for how to convince her. Uno and Ragan held their blades ready to drive through his body, but he did not appear to see them. “In the name of the Light, Nynaeve, please allow me to do what I can.”

It was a simple thing that finally tipped the balance in her mind. They were in Ghealdan. Amadicia was the only land that actually made a crime out of a woman being able to channel, and they were on the opposite bank of the river. That left only Galad’s oaths as a Child of the Light to battle against his duty to Elayne. She gave blood the edge in that struggle. Besides, he really was too gorgeous for her to let Uno and Ragan kill him. Not that that had anything to do with her decision, of course.

Robert Jordan, The Wheel of Time: The Fires of Heaven, Page 597 (via csi-middle-earth)