I’m just gonna ask a bunch of these since your tags said you were bored, feel free to ignore any/all of them lol. okay, top 5 Edain

already said Andreth

  1. Beren
  2. Bëor the Old
  3. Tuor
  4. Morwen or Rían
  5. …omg the me of several years ago doesn’t believe this but Túrin.

Now mortal OCs, the list goes:

  1. Kreka
  2. Bledda
  3. Bortë
  4. Boromir (he isn’t an OC but let’s be honest)

And honorable mentions to Haleth, Roas, Barahir and Emeldir, Lalaith, Bandir the Lame….

top 5 female characters and top 5 elves from anything. anything at all.

Elves, while I’ve read more than enough fantasy as to encounter hundreds, there’s a reason this is a Silm blog, so my top 5 elves?

  1. Finrod Felagund – actual noble king, loves humans and other mortals with every fiber of his immortal body and respects them, wishes to learn from them as much as share his own vast knowledge and prosperity, has a great death, his major flaw is treating people with more faith than they deserve.
  2. Ingwë Ingweron. So okay my head-canons count for a lot of this, but begin with this: the head elf of a species of incredible bad-ass assholes and leading his people to successfully defeat a big bad and to have almost un-interrupted lives of peace and prosperity and having never in the history of the world committed atrocities and terrible acts towards peaceful fellow sentient beings. That so little is known about him precisely because he didn’t leave the world worse off in some way, only ever better. If one is to have an archetypal Good Elf King, he is it.
  3. Lúthien Tinúviel. cheating on the elf here, add her to the other list. Action heroine without being one that does traditional fighting. Who uses singing and dancing and willpower and guile while staying a good person. Who is so very feminine coded but also undisputed the most powerful and successful hero in this book about epic heroes. Who loves this traumatized scruffy interloper, demands to be with him, argues with him when he tries to patronize, stands ups up to her powerful royal parents but is able to have some reconciliation and then still be independent of them. 
  4. Elu Thingol- you’re an ass but also a good king -or at least trying to be, who tries to protect his people and tries to protect their culture from being erased or subsumed, who has many flaws but for the most part is also self-aware of things like his temper and tries to make amends. (That is a rare and attractive trait). That he works as hero in some parts of the book (romantic one at that) and also the minor antagonist, and has a very Greek tragedy ending. He feels exactly like a main character of myth and epic while also being the ‘elven king’ on which all others are based. And fun to write.
  5. Círdan and Olwë tied for the novelty of sea/ship elf. Which you don’t see mariner elves in fantasy as much as you do in Tolkien, shame. Olwë for dropping truth bombs and being like Ingwë, Círdan for friend and ally award of every age and being the weary seen it all will be here to the end.

Okay, for five favorite female characters (and I won’t call this a top five list because like any time I’m asked to definitively rank I can’t) from fantasies I re-read or thought about recently:

  1. Already mentioned Lúthien, so putting Andreth here instead
  2. Catelyn Stark
  3. Sabriel
  4. Shallan
  5. Granny Weatherwax

and for meme #2, I recommend Heget’s fanfiction for anyone who likes their fic to be written by someone who is conversant in canon enough that any deviations are very deliberately in response to the canon work rather than being haphazard or simply because they don’t like something. She follows in the footsteps of Tolkien by filling in the margins, and she does so masterfully, with cultural tidbits and OCs who fit the world so well you’d believe they were canon if you didn’t know otherwise.

elfmaiddryope:

squirrelwrangler:

I have the blurb to add to the back covers of my works now 😉

Canon-like without being slavishly devoted to it is, I think, the goal of any fanfic writer, Tone-wise with the writing I can’t come close to capturing the feel. Read too much HoMe to be haphazard about canon sounds about right lol And one of the main purposes of fanfic is to explore the margins!

*pulls dryope aside, whispers* all those Ingwë of Cuiviènen fics are explicitly because I didn’t like canon Unbegotten elves or that Finwë, Elu, and Ingwë would have been such. Okay, I wiggled and bent the fuzzy canon to disprove that and then tried to beat the myth/fairy tale into submission with science while screaming in vain. Or BEST AU EVAR.

haha I should have clarified, simply was intended to mean “not liking something is not the beginning and end of deviating, she puts a lot of thought into her lore approach and it shows” 

I teased. But hey, at least with the Unbegotten, having them as separate characters, I sat down and thought about their psyches and then with Erikwa especially I found there was a concept I thought very cool, that if we are going to have fully-formed people dropped into the world as adults with absolutely no guidance or all-knowing figure there to explain the world or why they suddenly woke up, then those people are going to have issues and their children, who have parents and growing up and came into a world with predecessors and a society, aren’t. Which is why I think SF tropes work so well with the Unbegotten/Cuiviénen scenario.

And hey, BEST AU EVAR (i swear it’ll be written one day) was based on the very petty “Write Fëanor out of history” impulse, but then I tried to think it through to show okay there’d still be conflict and a lot of the War against Morgoth, just differently, that this would lead to a good justification for another AU I like the concept of, with the Noldor and Falmari switching roles and Elu/Olwë direct confrontations. That what’s lost is a MacGuffin for Beren and Lúthien to fetch, and the flavor of the war/conflict is less ‘The Exiles can never go back home, until Eärendil sails through’ and more ‘The ‘not!Exiles’ can’t convince everyone to Return back with them’. I think in this scenario, Morgoth has to be the one to burn the Swanships, so there’s still that lost forever treasure. (Oooh, Glaurung does it?)

So yeh, I’m trying to think my deviations through.

and for meme #2, I recommend Heget’s fanfiction for anyone who likes their fic to be written by someone who is conversant in canon enough that any deviations are very deliberately in response to the canon work rather than being haphazard or simply because they don’t like something. She follows in the footsteps of Tolkien by filling in the margins, and she does so masterfully, with cultural tidbits and OCs who fit the world so well you’d believe they were canon if you didn’t know otherwise.

I have the blurb to add to the back covers of my works now 😉

Canon-like without being slavishly devoted to it is, I think, the goal of any fanfic writer, Tone-wise with the writing I can’t come close to capturing the feel. Read too much HoMe to be haphazard about canon sounds about right lol And one of the main purposes of fanfic is to explore the margins!

*pulls dryope aside, whispers* all those Ingwë of Cuiviènen fics are explicitly because I didn’t like canon Unbegotten elves or that Finwë, Elu, and Ingwë would have been such. Okay, I wiggled and bent the fuzzy canon to disprove that and then tried to beat the myth/fairy tale into submission with science while screaming in vain. Or BEST AU EVAR.

woohoo, memes~ For the making you write things meme, my entirely selfish answer is Gorlim/Eilinel fluff because they’re my OTP and there is not enough fic of them. My slightly less selfish answer is more about the Band of the Red Hand before they ran off with Beren because you give so many great hints about their lives and I’m ;; at them

I had to look up which mutual wrote it, but @houseofhaleth‘s Gorlim and Eilinel (also here) was the first centered solely on them and now I completely and utterly believe that both were adorable introverts and Eilinel had a clubfoot -or because I re-read 1632: The Devil’s Opera recently and two of the main characters are ‘Stark’ Hans the prize fighter whose goal is to raise enough money for his sister who had her hip and leg shattered during the Sack of Madgeburg so i guess I could put my own spin oh hey the cop and Hans’ sister were a really cute couple in that I could make Edain expies and Gorlim becomes the son of the Bëorian equivalent of a town burger and one of the other twelve is now the Samson of Rvil’s Well. …Okay I have angle now so if I do get around to writing Gorlim/Eilinel I feel I could, because I love what jess has written for them.

As for the Band of the Red Hand, as I still have Aglar, Bân, Gadwar, and Edrahil to get through, there are more backstory and Nargothrond/pre-Nargothrond tidbits to go. Bân in particular is such a long piece because it’s flashbacks nestled in flashbacks and a majority of them located in Menegroth. Aglar’s story will be mostly back in Valinor- Formenos and then the Exile including the Sack of Alqualondë. Gadwar’s will have the most Nargothrond stuff, as my notes for him are all about his half-brother and him. I still have no idea what Edrahil wants his one-shot to be about. Everything else for them is post-First Age hanging out with Faron in The Hangover-esque fluff comedy.

and Edel from Princess Tutu ;D

general opinion: fall in a hole and die | don’t like them | eh | they’re fine I guess | like them! | love them | actual love of my life
hotness level: get away from me | meh | neutral | theoretically hot but not my type | pretty hot | gorgeous! | 10/10 would bang
hogwarts house: gryffindor | slytherin | ravenclaw | hufflepuff
best quality: kind and self-sacrificing even when she was/should have been nothing but an automaton plot device for Drosselmeyer
worst quality: She was only a puppet, and is destroyed/dies and replaced by Uzura who was a cute character but also annoying and would have rather kept Edel
ship them with: no one
brotp them with: Uzura, Ahiru, Fakir, whoever the narrator is
needs to stay away from: Drosselmeyer, open flames
misc. thoughts: How the heck does her hair work? Mostly just that ring of curls- how does it attach in the back? Also now thanks to Over the Garden Wall I can’t help but think she was carved from Edelwood trees. Also- perfect crossover OtGW and PT

It literally just occurred to me I don’t have to stick to the Silm for this meme, right??? so. Moiraine Damodred

general opinion: fall in a hole and die | don’t like them | eh | they’re fine I guess | like them! | love them | actual love of my life
hotness level: get away from me | meh | neutral | theoretically hot but not my type | pretty hot | gorgeous! | 10/10 would bang
hogwarts house: gryffindor? | slytherin | ravenclaw | hufflepuff …ask @anghraine. Whatever the Blue Ajah is
best quality: Gandalf/Obi-wan/Dumbledore is a middle-aged woman that should not be as revolutionary as it is, She’s gonna save the world with her crafty plans and admits when she needs to change tactics, she does care about her Chosen One, she’s snarky without being mean, has flaws
worst quality: Dumbledore-like close-lipped controlling behavior backfires
ship them with: Thom, Siuan
brotp them with: Lan, Siuan, Egwene, Verin, those Grey twins, Matt and Perrin and the various Aiel
needs to stay away from: Lanfear, the Snakes and Foxes
misc. thoughts: It’s been too long, i can’t remember most everyone’s names or plot things that happened especially in the last two books

Nellas for the character meme

general opinion: fall in a hole and die | don’t like them | eh | they’re fine I guess | like them! | love them | actual love of my life
hotness level: get away from me | meh | neutral | theoretically hot but not my type | pretty hot | gorgeous! | 10/10 would bang 

hogwarts house: gryffindor | slytherin | ravenclaw? | hufflepuff
best quality: She’s very cute. She was fulling willing and patient to take a small mortal child under her wing and teach him
worst quality: i don’t know much about her. Um, I can’t judge her at all for being shy and being afraid to testify in public- that’s a best relatable quality.
ship them with: precocious crush on Mablung or Beleg, idk?
brotp them with: Túrin, Mablung, Beleg, Beren and Lúthien (headcanon that she knew Lúthien -wasn’t she a handmaiden of Melian?- and at least met Beren and they bonded over wildlife and how awesomely nice friends trees can be and that’s why Nellas latched onto teaching Túrin)
needs to stay away from: Kinslayers (the knowledge that there’s a 90% chance she died in the Second Kinslaying breaks my heart), orcs, people who demolish trees, people who hate the Sindar, Nandor, and/or mortals
misc. thoughts: Influenced now to picture her as very young (for an elf), so concepts of her hotness or shipping her with others gets very iffy for me. Also still haven’t read CoH for more Nellas. It’s understood that she has brown hair, right?

3 and 33 for this fic writing meme

  • 3: what motivates you?

SPITE. 

Okay, that’s a gross exaggeration and not entirely accurate for every story I’ve written. But to out-pour all my love for Indis, Elu and the Sindar, write about the Valar, Bëorians up in Dorthonion, wax eloquently and profusely on the Swanships, that the Bór will dump the Fëanorians just like Huan and all dogs did – that writerly effort is loving in defiance of not just fans and fandom wank, but for instance my anger at how the Game of Thrones TV ruined the only characters/plot that held my interest in ASoIaF is why I wrote as much as I did for Release from Bondage. On nicer notes, I’m also inspired by songs and footnotes and of course the ‘how can I make this fusion work?’

  • 33: favorite one-shot you’ve written?

I hold a large litter of puppies in my arms, as the fluffy little things squirm in my grip, you ask me to pick just one. I stare at you.

Uh, maybe Grief is an Undertow.  Ilsë’s list of the unjustly slain is my id candy and the fundamental anger of the Teleri is me as this tower of salt.