2, 4, 11, 12, 16, 18, 29

2. What’s your favourite elf (can be Noldor or not)?

So many, but if i had to pick one and only one, I go back to the first I fell in love with: Indis. By the Belain, the moment when her oldest son is threatened with death- and her husband -her son’s father and their king- sides with who has threatened to murder their son? Who abandons her, their children and life together, and their people, for this step-son who has threatened to murder his half-brother? That she stays with her children until everything falls apart and only then leaves -still with one of her daughters. That she threw herself whole-heartedly into the role as queen of a people not her own, adopting their speech and custom, and that her two sons grew to be wise and forgiving and strong kings (and their wise manner rightfully attributed to her). That she suffered and was abandoned in the worst way by a husband, but had the loyalty of her children. Such a tiny role on the pages of the Silm, but her character and the goodness shone out to me somehow. I read the ‘Statute of Finwë and Míriel’ carrying not at all about those two, just searching for what little else I could learn about Indis and if the wrongs upon her were redressed.

4. What’s your favourite Valar?

OOooh. Ummm. Oromë? Tulkas and Nessa? Yavanna and Aulë? Nienna? Námo? …probably Námo.

11. Do you agree with the way the Valar dealt with Middle-earth?

Answered. In part because of the hate heaped up on them, I reflectively counter back. It’s hard having half a heart Vanyar and the other Sindar. The Eglath have an honest grievance against the Valar; the Noldor don’t.

12. Doriath or Nargothrond?

As fun as writing the Nargothrond Soap Opera with assorted OCs, Doriath and Menegroth holds my heart. There is a romance and a sadness in my heart that it touches deep down. (Of my least favorite places in Beleriand, it’s not Angband because hey, writing opportunities! but Himring and Himlad)

16. What do you think of Fingolfin going to attack Melkor?

It’s a classic epic scene – in the old-school meaning of the word. And Fingolfin isn’t fool-hardly enough to think himself the combat equal of Melkor – and yet in his last act of defiance, of ensuring he is selling his death as dearly as possibly, he permanently and grievously wounds the Satan figure itself. Plus Fingolfin is reeling under suicidal grief and he just lost the only princes among the Noldor who were willing to listen and agree with his plans and urging to fight Morgoth. (Yes, I have the Blind Guardian album too, and Time Stands Still is a good rock song.)

18. What do you think Eru meant by “And thou, Melkor, shalt see that no theme may be played that hath not its uttermost source in me, nor can any alter the music in my despite. For he that attempteth this shall prove but mine instrument in the devising of things more wonderful, which he himself hath not imagined.”?

My theology is….about what someone raised without it would be ;). But pretty straight forward, Eru is the Creator of Everything. Plus given enough time the common decency of people overcomes the evil. I’m an optimist enough to believe that, and this is a fantasy universe that runs on that principle of the eucatastrophy.

29. If you were an elf in Midlle-earth after the War of Wrath would you sail immediately to Valinor or wait a little more in Middle-earth?

Answered and answered. 🙂

6, and for shits and giggles, 22

You terrible person you

6. Would you have followed Fëanor?

Look, this would mean I’d consider Fëanor having the bare minimum requirements of what I consider a good leader. Especially politically and militarily. Someone who sacrifices advantages for his people based on his personal ambitions and prejudices is a nope. Someone who doesn’t show concern and consideration for his sons’ lives, let alone followers or subjects, is an astoundingly bad leader. Someone who in his megalomania and hubris thinks himself seriously the equal if not superior to Melkor has no judgment. And Someone who is a clear parallel to Melkor (and Lucifer) is no one I want to associate with, let alone trust to lead me successfully anyway.

So again, No chance in Utumno 😉 

22. If you could marry one of Fëanor’s sons which one would you choose?

Okay, am I marrying them as to get close enough to assassinate one or several of them? Because that would be my goal, to be honest.

Fu~ If I was forced at sword-point to marry one of the terrible seven, I would pick Amrod. He is the ONLY son of Fëanor to go against the emotional control/blackmail of his father, defy the old man, and try to return to his mother and Aman. Nor does he have the absolute black reputation and deeds of his brothers (Tolkien uses the word evil to describe Curufin- how more explicit can you be?). Still, Amras is a mass murderer who swore that Oath, but at least if we go by the Losgar Incident he dies early, nice short marriage. And if I’m lucky he stays in Mandos and I can remarry someone better.

Ingwë: ■ ▼ ൠ ☼ ☾ ☮ ♦

☾ – sleep headcanon

The beds of Cuiviénen and the Journey were layers of woven straw mats cushioned by felt, then more felt and blankets of wool and fur, and small hard pillows, if not just a blanket folded as headrest. As Imin and Iminyë before, Ingwë sleeps on a wide sleeping mat made for two, and it is when halfway through the Journey when Ravennë joins him to sleep in the central mat that the tribe officially recognizes king and queen (they were getting worried). Ingwë sleeps on his side, eyes open like the Minyar do – a habit from the Unbegotten, who fear sleep as the return to the unknown state that they came from, as they do not know how or why they first awoke and if they might someday stop. (All of this is my Imin and Iminyë one-shot I’ll post in-full eventually). Ravennë kicks in her sleep; Ingwë’s successful marriage depends in-part on never bringing this up with her 😉 They don’t always share a bed, as Ingwë is often up in Ilmarin on meditative retreats while his wife stays in Valmar for ruling. She does murmur and not-quite-snore, but very audibly breathe when she sleeps, maybe because Ingwë is so still and silent as he does. But he finds it a very comforting and relaxing thing, the sounds of his wife sleeping next to him, and sometimes he pretends to sleep, waiting and just listening to her, the ache of loneliness soothed away. The cats sleep on the bed when Ravennë is away, so their purring drives away the quiet – though yes, Ingwë has awoken in a panic because one of the cats has fallen asleep on his face, and yes, the times they have forgotten to kick the cats out and lock the door before sex are pathetically higher than that number should be (someone keeps forgetting).

■ –  Bedroom/house/living quarters headcanon

In Cuiviénen there was a hut without finished walls, a slanting thatch roof and a couple woven floor mats, some pots from Finwë, and a large pile of furs and hide blankets, and a beautiful wooden box from Elwë in which Ingwë stored his family treasures and hunting tools. This was on the outer ring of the village, farthest from the great central bonfires. (Status counted how far your house was from the light)

Once Ingwë becomes chief, and when he builds his new home in Aman, his rooms are infused with bright light. He likes wooden furniture with simple lines but bright colors.

Everything is covered in cat hair. He tells the servants not to bother trying to remove all if it.

On the Great Journey they had a tent and sleeping mats. When in Valinor the Noldor help to design the tall tower Mindolin, but Ingwë leaves it soon after. He stays in a monastery for mediation penance for murder high in the mountains close to Ilmarin, which over time becomes as elaborate as the palace in Valmar. Still, the lines are clean and work around nature, the furnishings simple, sparse, and mostly of pale light woods (lot of balsa) – though again designwise so many throw rugs and cushions and pillows and furs. What Ingwë has the most of are books and scrolls – he writes and loves to read poetry. The servants are better at cleaning away the ink (though again, cats~) than the pet hair.

Stylistically more Art Deco than Art Nouveau – Ingwë is going to love imported dwarven designs.

☮ – friendship headcanon

His first friend was Asmalô, the Minyar born right before him. The two were ‘milk brothers’ – their mothers shared nursing duties. Growing up Ingwë wanted to be a hunter alongside his friend, do everything together, but after the accident, Asmalô and his mom treated Ingwë’s family as outcasts the same as the rest of the tribe, so Ingwë cut him off. Asmalô (named for the yellow hammer bird) kept an eye on his former friend out of guilt, so vaguely knew what Ingwë was up to, and was the one to cover for him (without prompting) when Ingwë sneaked away from the village to help Elwë hunt the Dark Hunters. When Ingwë comes back with Oromë, Asmalô is ecstatic and basically pimping his friend to be restored with all the great honors back into the tribe. He’s going to be Ingwë’s #2 among the warrior/young hunter cadres of the Minyar, and the one that watches Imin’s son for signs of rebellion/disobedience. Again a lot of this is coming out of Asmalô’s personal initiative trying to make up for guilt.

♦ – quirks/hobbies headcanon

So much poetry. So much explicit poetry about how great married life with his wife is. Philosophical musings. Finely crafted words to describe the sounds and colors of the mountains. He loves Rúmil for inventing writing so he can record his thoughts and words. Poetry about his cats, poetry written in the shape of cats. So much dirty poetry one doesn’t realize is really sexual unless one knows their metaphors. Ingwë’s kids try to explain it away by admitting that especially for the chieftains during the march, such things weren’t private but had an audience so it’s not that their parents are exhibitionists. But life is so less embarrassing and quiet when their parents are up in the monastery. And isn’t four kids enough? No?

Ironically he’s pretty private otherwise, at least to talk. But in his poetry all his opinions and thoughts come out. Lot of sappy stuff about colors and mountain sunrises. And how cute the noises his wife makes as she falls asleep.

Ingwë also breeds cats. Loud white with dark tip cats with mostly blue or green eyes.

▼ – childhood headcanon

Ingwë is the equivalent of about eleven when his parents are badly injured on the hunt and can no longer successfully or easily provide. From that point onward Ingwë is the one to support his family. He was solemn as a child; after this he becomes frightfully stoic. It is only after some time with Elwë and Finwë the other boys make him laugh for the first in a long time. The first few times he tries to hunt for food he fails until he learns about staying downwind from prey.

☼ – appearance headcanon

Ingwë is not as tall as Elwë (nobody is) or Turgon, but he’s definitely tall for an elf, Maedhros or taller. Indis is also very tall- that’s where Nolofinwë, Turgon, and Argon get their height. (Of Arafinwë’s kids, I see Aegnor as ironically the tallest, though where that’s the royal Sindar coming through or not, I’m not sure. Finwë btw is the short fat one of his friends.)  Very muscular, smooth not-quite-longish face with high but not sharp cheekbones, full lips. Golden skin, lighter gold hair with a dense curl texture. Very blue eyes. Wears his hair short, even when the style is to have it long. Every once and a while is convinced to grow it out, but doesn’t stay. Feathered crown, white clothes, likes hose/fine-cut tights instead of the long robe look.

ൠ – random headcanon

One of Ingwë’s favorite things is to give advice, but he never does unless someone prompts him to. He’s really independent and doesn’t go to others to work through options or advice; it’s not his natural first inclination, part and parcel of growing up as as the isolated independent breadwinner. So his family and advisers learn they have to actively go to Ingwë and ask him what his opinion is/ for advice, which then it’s like a switch flipping and Ingwë pours out with ideas and suggestions (and also lays out his plans and what he’d pick).

Fix-it AU or Canon Divergence AU? Steampunk AU or Cyberpunk AU? Crossovers or Fusions? :)

Oh… to be honest a Fix-it AU in a good author is fun, which there’s that fine line to keep it from being just wish fulfillment god-mode-ing but I’m reading fix-its for certain fandoms for a reason 😉 But if the fic is just a Canon Divergence, then unless it’s doing the Grimdark angst-fest, that tells me the author is hopefully thinking through the consequences of this butterfly wing flap. Uuuh, i know I’m waffling….. a Canon Divergence that ends up a Fix-it by its conclusion. 😀

I like Steampunk (and Diesel and Clockpunk) a lot more than Cyberpunk. partially because I’m a huge fan of historical fiction, even if it’s SF time-travel versions of it, whereas not only do I have very little interest in the cybertech or twenty-minutes-in-the-future settings. Just the general feel is that cybertech stories, thanks to their Noir roots, have this cynical dystopian trend, whereas I know a steampunk AU has better chances of being silly or hopeful. One takes itself less seriously as a setting prompt. Generally speaking.

Fusions! Without a doubt. They’re what I write anyway (it’s funny how many fusions I have), and I find them more creative and easier to write, plus more satisfying. Unless the canon is centered around universe-hopping as to encourage conflicting canons to interact, having separate crossover characters interacting outside of parody doesn’t hold a plot nor is as enjoyable for me to read, tbh.

B, A, D, W, O, L, F :)

  • B – A pairing you initially didn’t consider but someone changed your mind

Trying to think of examples (that aren’t just, hey this canon couple you didn’t notice, it’s great and give it a look)…

Stannis/Davos wasn’t something I picked up from the books, but fans emphasized it, so now it’s a brOTP I love (romantically I can take or leave).

anghraine makes a good case for F!Faramir/Aragorn, which I’d never ship otherwise.

  • A – Your current OTP(s)/OT3(s)/OTX(s)

Answered with a bunch of examples in previous post. See L.

  • D – A pairing you wish you liked but just can’t (again: be nice)

Anything from Legend of Korra. And AtLA would be better if I force myself to like Kataang (just, ugh. Honestly Aang took a long time for me to stop actively disliking him, and he and definitely his crush felt too immature)

  • W – 5 favorite ships and 5 kinks you like best for said ships

(Damn, I don’t have a handy lists of kinks, but I’ll try my best. Also, too much a prude to list out the sexual ones.)

Bodyguard Crush, especially gender-flipped. Roy/Riza and Ling/Ran Fan are good examples. Devoted serious girl protecting (physically and as a moral boost/restraint) her genuinely good-hearted but forced into political and moralistic dangers and quagmires boy. The regular bodyguard crush trope as well, but I like twist to my knight and maiden scenarios. A big one for me is what I’d call the Dark Empress and Her Knight, where the guy is the devoted warlord but his queen is sealed calamity in a can or more powerful/the one ruling, and he is amused that people fear him when they should her. The noble demon type villains inverse of the knight and maiden. I can name a lot of my original characters that have this dynamic, or AUs for fandom pairings, but actual examples…. Dark!Anakin/Padmé perhaps. Regular canon version for them of course is the bodyguard and m’lady. Also the defrosting ice queen guy making pragmatic decisions to protect cheerful girl’s happiness. Height differences.

Aoshi/Misao.

There’s a running theme of dynamics here. As far as fanfic tropes I also love more than I should, the fake marriage turns to real affection and its even better older sibling, the Perfectly Arranged Marriage! Fusion/Crossovers! Combine or parallel a couple of these things and you get Beauty and the Beast (Belle always was my fav). In a strange way happy ending Theon/Jeyne ends up here too. Reunited in the afterlife – Zack/Aerith. 

  • O – Choose a song at random, which ship or character does it remind you of

*turns on radio* first song is Mountain Sound, which as  I listen does make a great Tolkien roadtrip song. Maybe Gimli and Legolas?

  • L – Say something genuinely nice about a character who isn’t one of your faves (chars you’re neutral on are fair game, as are chars you dislike)

I’m neutral on Túrin, but damn if he doesn’t try to do the right thing. And he was making an honest attempt at a peaceful under-the-radar life with Nienor, and he did kill Glaurung. Without Gandalf Middle-earth would have fallen to Sauron.

Rand was under insane pressure and tried his best, take away the taint and ruling and prophecy pressures and he was a very good friend. And good musician. Min’s superpowers was one of the best and most inventive things in that series and fueled a lot of the fan-guessing that ran that series.

Dany can show a great deal of compassion and is trying to do the right thing by freeing the slaves and improving the lives of those without power she comes across. Without her dragons she would have had little power to save her own life, let alone anyone else.

  • F – What’s the longest you’ve ever been in a fandom

I’ve lurked in fandoms online since middle school, so of those, RuroKen was the first one I actively searched for manga translations and webrings and fansites for character shrines and fanfiction (Ah, the Akabeko site). Also some other anime of that time – Inuyasha I know, but I missed the big three of Evangelion, Fushigi Yuugi, and Escaflowne. But 1999 was also the year Phantom Menace came out, so I remember the drive that summer to my grandpa where the car discussion was explaining Star Wars, my parents deciding to remedy the glaring omission in our education by renting the OT, and my mom going out and buying some SW books – two of the childrens’ novelizations of TPM from the viewpoint of Padmé and Anakin, and some of the X-Wing novels. Never saw TPM in theaters, but bought it on video, my sisters and I were majorly hooked on everything, I read all the Bantam Era novels I could find at my library, saw AotC twice in theaters (which is one of the only films I’ve paid to see twice). I obsessively followed theforce.net sometime after the second film, greedily wanting spoilers for RotS, read the legacy discussion boards and fanfic. Never read NJO or played any of the video games, fannish obsession has weaned off over the years a tad, but yeah, 16 years for that one as well. Oh, and Tolkien. Funny story that one. Technically younger than a bunch of other fandoms by like a year or so.

Silmarillion :)

  1. my beautiful cinnamon roll too good for this world fave: Dior, Elwing, Indis, Beren (too many~)
  2. my trash-shit fave: Maeglin (as in you inspired an original character that defines this for me)
  3. my I love to hate them fave: Castamir is LotR  Morgoth, Thu 
  4. my I hate to love them fave: Eöl
  5. my I wouldn’t piss on them if they were on fire non-fave: Fëanor (HA-HA)
  6. my I didn’t care about them either way at first but the fandom makes such a big deal about them now I can’t stand them non-fave: definition of: Maedhros, also Fingon, Maglor
  7. my I could take them or leave them kinda non-fave: Galadriel, Fingolfin, Ereinion Gil-galad
  8. my I will go down with this ship and I won’t put my hands up and surrender, there will be no white flag above my door. I’m in love and always will be fave ship: Beren/Lúthien
  9. my dirtybadwrong fave ship: Túrin/Nienor, Aredhel/Eöl
  10. my they’re cute together and I dig them but I’m not all that terribly invested kinda fave ship: Galadriel/Celeborn, Tuor/Idril
  11. my I didn’t care about this ship either way at first but the fandom makes such a big deal about it now I can’t stand it non-fave ship: Maedhros/Fingon and Melkor/Sauron
  12. my MAKE IT STOP non-fave ship: Celegorm/Lúthien (WHY GODS NO), Celegorm/Aredhel, most incest ships