Indis, Bortë, Kaoru

All lovely, heart-hearted, and stubborn ladies! (I like and focus on male characters quite a bit too, but yes, this is most delightful group) It’s funny, I still think of Kate as the real Indis-mum, and despite the lopsided re-blogging, Misao is my favorite (female or otherwise) character from RuroKen. Not that Kaoru isn’t second, and in the top five of overall favorites. And yay, my OC queen!

Elmo

  • My NOTP for them – any incest ship. he’s very obscure, so I don’t see any pairings for him, objectionable or otherwise. hmm, the standard NOTP: Any Fëanorian or other kinslayer
  • My BROTP for them – his big brothers definitely. Eredhon, that bundle of nerves that is Linkwînen’s brother. Oropher 
  • My OTP for them – my OC Linkwînen
  • My second choice pairing for them –  another OC to describe the textual ghost of his canon wife
  • My fluffy pairing for them –  reed-girl Linkwînen
  • My angsty pairing for them – aside from the mandatory repeat answer, Elu’s angsty thoughts about his dead brother is still may favorite of my short, quickly-written fics.
  • My favorite poly ship for them – ….. ┐(‘~`)┌
  • My weirdest pairing for them – I want him to meet Elmo Tully now and have a fun time carousing around forested woodlands partying like only backstory-only distant ancestors of important canon characters who share a name with an annoying red muppet can (it’s an exclusive club).

Feanor, Maedhros, Maglor, Caranthir, Curufin (sorry i couldn’t resist i will send you a better one in a minute)

(I figured I was tempting fate for a terrible 7)

OOHH Dear this is the “who do I hate less”, with added “who is less lionized and whitewashed by fans in a way that doesn’t disgust me”, and some ‘well at least this character is such an effective and enjoyable to hate’ villain. So combining the three categories of A) terrible person who did awful things for selfish motives, and B) can’t stand to see them on my dash, against C) works as antagonists for actually likable characters :

  1. Caranthir (remove my NOTP with Haleth and he’s rarely put on a pedestal, amusingly outwitted by Ulfang, good antagonist)
  2. Curufin (pathetic slime-ball described as evil by Tolkien, good blatant antagonist)
  3. Maedhros (overrated and annoyed at how he’s given Finrod’s good qualities, boring and sick of his fanart)
  4. Maglor (overexposed, overrated, painted as saintly when he has the highest body-count, kidnapped children and glorified as their father for it **RAGE BUTTON**, like Maedhros boring rehash of same angsty fic and art)
  5. Fëanor (Was almost third place before his two sons, but then…nah fascist xenophobic egotistic asshole mischaracterized as this free-thinker right in his rebellion that Doomed and Damned his people and believed Melkor’s lies while thinking himself greater – he’s blatantly the elf parallel to Melkor so nah you still get last place)

Ingwë, Indis, Amarië, Elemmírë, Finarfin? :)

  1. Indis
  2. Ingwë
  3. Finarfin
  4. Amarië
  5. Elemmírë

Indis is always my forever girl :), and I have always loved and deeply admired Finarfin, though Ingwë thanks to head-canon developments and fic rocketed his way into the top tier (plus wise king that never disappointed or led astray his people or ever assaulted another free folk is rare and precious in Tolkien). Amarië I also have quite the affection and some headcanons for, but Elemmírë I can’t definitively decide on a gender, so they have bottom slot for that reason.

your fave fic about edain/eldar interactions, ✄ ♡ ☠ ★

OOooh man I don’t even know which story to pick? Do I go with one of the Angrod and the Bëor (which would probably be Irongrip and Rage-Bunny unless I go with the Gone Fishing or the Boromir in the Swamps ficlets)? Or the trilogy of old Bór women mouthing off in exasperation and disgust to the Fëanorians?

*spins the wheel of indecision*

The collective Bór quartet, for ease of answering

  • ✄: something i deleted before the final draft

ah, I’m terrible in that I add to my drafts more than I can remember deleting things. Though i do know at least in my initial conception of the story that would the latest one with Borte the First, there was a stronger emphasis on her seen as this witch figure, and the warriors of Ulfang assaulting her daughters(-in-law). I do know in earlier versions of my idea, Bór was still alive post-Nirneath – that he was bed-ridden and dying when Ulfang/Lorgan’s warriors come, so Borte has to leave from tending his side to throw them out, so there’s the old Bór dying in the backroom so to speak while this is happening and Borte uses that as part of shaming the hostile warriors away, and then when Bór dies (idk? i think maybe he died in the middle of this face-off stuff?) that’s when Borte flees. But it was much simpler and more streamlined to have Bór die right before the Nirnaeth gets into gear, thus leaving Uldor less opposition and as this dark omen over the Bór going in.

  • ♡: my favorite part 

Of the first one with Kreka, my favorite part still is when she kneels over the prayer rug, because the pose and the feeling of the carpet in her hands and the helplessness was so visceral when I wrote it and still is, and these thoughts of doubt and how she sees the options that aren’t options before and behind her and the memories of her family and the examples of her ancestors that she doesn’t know if she can uphold. It’s the core of …everything.

  • ☠: something i found challenging 

Kreka’s talk to the Fëanorians in the second fic (more the wrapping up that speech and their last words and making sure the flow of the conversation- I had the points and various lines, but making sure it flowed. And correcting the timeline intervals for everything to fit with canon). Then when I got to Borte it was hard to make sure it wasn’t too similar. And I went back to the dialogue a lot and added quite a bit to Maglor’s presence and made him more openly defending and welcoming to the Bór (but still that moment where he switches over and sides with his brothers because they are Fëanorians and only their direct kin count in the end. If I didn’t have that, I’d be wildly mis-characterizing those characters from the book) Also the packing scenes. What do these semi-nomadic people pack their items in and how do they carry them…

  • ★: something i’m proud to have accomplished 

I wrote several popular-ish stories off of mostly OC human characters from a group that had all of two or three lines in the Silmarillion. The stories made at least one reader think “what happened to the People of Bór?”

Interest and excitement for these Good-Guy Easterlings ♥