@squirrelwrangler I feeeeel you about the debate undercurrent. I see tooooons of engagement on my dash! I don’t interact with all (or even most) of it, but it’s there so….idk, I’ve never really cared for that whole overarching “we’re a community because we all love this book” thing? I DO like finding people who enjoy the same books as me! But I have a hard time if we don’t like them for the same reasons. I think…I like people who enjoy the same THEMES and approach their fandoms in the same way I do more, even if we don’t have a lot of fandom overlap, if that makes sense? My BFF can’t care less about Tolkien or Sailor Moon; he’s into X-Men and Star Trek. But we approach fandom the same way and we like the same themes, so we’re compatible! And it’s why I like reading your DC posts even though I know literally nothing about DC comics, because I feel like our approaches and interests overlap even if the fandoms themselves don’t.
Yes! The wider fandom can be good for memes and jokes and fan art, but I don’t want to interact with a community at whole, just find those likeminded fans. And that it’s what themes and character types that are most important 🙂 it makes it so I can follow mutuals’ fandoms and their meta and such of which I have little or no knowledge, but because the foundation of the enjoyment comes from a similar place. Or find weird theme sharing (Suicide Squad and Naruto)
The DC and DCEU is so funny to me, because yeah, almost all my followers are Tolkien/Silm and yet many can enjoy the dc stuff. And I think there is a serious correlation in underlying themes and tastes but I can’t put my finger on all of them. (Definitely more than MCU) and the fuzziness and openness of canon is a weirdly comforting similiarity.
Haha but hearing about mutual’s fandoms is fun c:
Also I legit just pinpointed why the current debate is getting under my skin. The focus on fanfic as the primary form of engagement is what bothers me the most I think. I don’t read fic because it’s in my fandom; I read it if it looks like it will hit my narrow interests within the fandom. Is that improperly engaging?! It’s such a strange focus to me, to narrow fandom down to fanfic.
Ah yes – I think there is a meta component to the interaction complaint, but yeah – there are fandoms (and sub fandoms) where I don’t want to read fic but meta, or fanart. Some where I just want a fan to agree it’s awesome and that’s it. And Silm I write but don’t read fic, and the fandom focus even ten years ago wasn’t what I cared about.


