rose-of-the-bright-sea replied to your post:
I forget how inane and common it is, but I tried…
*is guilty of complaining about DC’s color use* Sorry. Especially since it’s flooding the movie’s tags. You should get to enjoy that without the snide comments.
It’s just- SOOO F*CKING COMMON. Articles and podcasts about Star Trek, or other non-related fandoms or movies, let alone other DC properties have to bring that complaint or ones similar. I forget how common it is, that it’s the thing to do, and then I actually read anything entertainment-related online. And it’s exactly like the prequel bashing from the 2000s. I can’t follow anything Superman because god forbid there’s this version that isn’t some mythic nostalgia version from the late 70s movies or 90s comic that they say they want (and then contract themselves on what makes a good Superman).
I would listen to a podcast reviewing the John Byrne era Superman comics, and be baffled that the hosts were praising what the storytellers were doing – for almost the same damn things MoS was bashed for.
They’ve forever tainted the John Williams Superman theme for me, btw. I hate it.
But dare MoS exists, this one that was filmed specifically with the styling of a documentary, to lack artificially adjusting the skin-tones,
often the scenes are shot so that there is focus on one intense color (usually a red cape or the orange sunset of a dying Krypton, any time with the green kryptonite). Which is just not allowed to be the visual style for an action comedy – and the reviews for Teen Titans Go and Lego Batman made it clear that only satires are acceptable DC films anyway. Where were the people bitching about the color in the Deadpool movies? (Which, I laughed at them, but there’s a teenage frat boy’s humor, a snarkiness, that I completely understand why people wouldn’t like them for good reason. The spoofing of the genre that I also liked in the first GotG – but also the first GotG had moments of earnest heart whereas watching GotG2 was the most unfunny and non-enjoyable movie theater experience that I’ve ever had, even if the film was brightly saturated. Just, wow, I can’t remember paying for a ticket for a movie that I hated watching that much. Not even Ultron was that bad).
I remember great lines from MCU films, but the only movie of the twenty that I will regularly think back and go “the images were beautiful and memorable to look at” is the first Thor. Okay, and the Thor movie is the only other one that I regularly remember the themes and musical motifs. I definitely have my tastes. Look, I’ve accepted that Thor is my Wonder Woman, the one that I’ll go “well the rest of the films aren’t good, but we can agree this one was good”. Well, except the general consensus nowadays is that only Ragnarok was good.
And I’m going to be petty and finally type my feelings on this: the Airport scene in Civil War (and most of that movie, c’mon people) is really ugly. Like, I can’t look at it without thinking of how godawful it looks. There’s only middle tones, and grayed, washed out ones at that, because they filmed digital and didn’t color grade, and it is a ugly gray movie, but hey, billion dollars profit and daylight scenes and constant quips and undercutting stakes with a wink and nod at the audience these are escapism films to snark with and therefore ‘more colorful’.
…sorry. it’s past midnight, I have no filter on the rant that simmers under my skin for months now (and I could point at Justice League and every single Whedon reshot scene where I could see the quality in both writing and cinematography dip – but the bloggers got the changes that they were demanding, including Elfman’s score, hooray), and I swear, if it wasn’t bashing BvS, it was complaints about how dare the Death of Superman movie rush to reestablish the Superman/Lois relationship. Like, wow, that was a mistake to go into that tag. Amazing, the Venn Diagram one could make between people who disliked Lois Lane and the DCEU films…
Sorry, this is a rant properly aimed at the void.